Several years after I tossed Michael
Chricton's Eater's of the Dead into the used book bag, having only read, at best, thirty pages and cussing him for blatant plagiarism, I read the afterward of the book. If memory serves (its not worth
wikipeding), some friend of
Chricton's complained that students were no longer interested in the classics. It was some how impossible to get them interested in such older works as
Beowulf.
Chricton's response was that it just wasn't presented right... and he wrote the above mentioned retelling of the story... which I never finished.... Robert
Zemeckis' response is the movie,
Beowulf, I saw today, and I can only say that he hit the nail on the head... I am sure that the images I saw on the screen today were very close to those that listeners would have imagined as the poem was song around campfires long ago.
I was a bit surprised to see that the movie is animated much like
300 without the
herky-jerky stop motion/speed motion of that film. The animation is also not often as good as that of
300, but making it a little more video-
gamey than 300 may help connect with that lost generation that so disturbed
Chricton's friend. Once I got adjusted to the animation, I just went along for the enjoyable ride.
The poem,
Beowulf is one of my favorite works, and the ancient
Geat one of my first heroes. Until now, all the screen adaptations I've seen were pretty pathetic, mainly because they either focused only on the conflict with Grendel or just used the name Beowulf, and the poem itself be damned....
Zemeckis does none of this. He stays truer to the story than anyone in the past, and because the various parts of the story need to be connected somehow, I will grant him the changes that he made to Grendel's Dam and fate of Hrothgar.
The movie shows the swimming race between Beowulf and
Brecca and the battle with the sea monsters, and just like those listeners nearly 2000 years ago, I can accept Beowulf's abilities, for he was the first superhero. there is also a scene where the kingdom celebrates the anniversary of Grendel's death by telling the story of his fight with Beowulf, and the bard is telling the story in Old English which was a delightful touch. I also enjoyed the
brief scene when
Unferth asked Hrothgar if they should also sacrifice to the 'new god, Christ Jesus.'
Zemeckis illustrates, in this single scene, the influences of Christianity that each lecture spends at least 45 minutes addressing. I thought that too was a nice touch.
So, if you like the poem,
Beowulf, you should not be disappointed with this film... If you are a fan of superheroes... well, this was the first, and you should enjoy this film... If you need exact realism in your science fiction and fantasy.. you might not like this, and if you are an English professor and think that
Beowulf is no longer teachable to the modern student... just wait so your class can get the DVD....
Bottom line: I recommend this movie....